Metering through an orifice
All flow control valves work by forcing flow through an adjustable restriction. For a given opening, flow through the orifice depends on the pressure drop across it: in hydraulics roughly with the square root of the drop, in pneumatics with upstream pressure and, above the critical ratio, choked at sonic velocity. This dependence is the central problem the different designs solve to different degrees.
Why a plain needle drifts
With a simple restrictor, actuator speed is only constant while load pressure is constant. When a cylinder meets more resistance, the pressure drop across the orifice falls and flow drops with it, so the actuator slows exactly when the work gets harder. For clamping, damping and setup adjustments this is acceptable; for feed rates it is not.
Pressure compensation
A pressure-compensated flow control adds a spring-loaded compensator spool that senses the drop across the metering orifice and throttles upstream flow to hold that drop constant, typically at 5 to 8 bar. With a fixed drop across a fixed orifice, flow is fixed regardless of load, holding speed within a few percent from no load to full load. Temperature compensation goes further, using a sharp-edged orifice whose discharge is nearly viscosity-independent, so speed holds as the oil warms through a shift.
The bypass check
In a one-way speed controller, a lightly sprung check element sits in parallel with the needle. In the metered direction the check holds shut and all flow crosses the orifice; in reverse the check lifts and flow bypasses freely. Failure of this small element, from contamination holding it open or its soft seat eroding, shows up as loss of speed control in one direction and is the most common fault in pneumatic controllers.
Meter-out dynamics
Throttling the outlet keeps the actuator under back pressure, so an overrunning load cannot run away; the cylinder is hydraulically or pneumatically caged between supply and restricted exhaust. The cost is higher pressure on the rod side (intensification in cylinders with large area ratios can exceed supply pressure, which matters for seal rating) and, in pneumatics, slightly spongier response. Meter-in gives smoother breakaway on sticky loads but no control over an overrunning load.
Failure modes and why details matter
Contamination is the dominant killer: silt partially blocks small orifices and shifts the set flow, so filtration to the manufacturer's cleanliness class matters more than brand. Vibration walks unlocked adjustment screws; specify locknuts or detented knobs on machines with vibration. In pneumatics, undersized controllers choke and cap cylinder speed regardless of setting, so size on flow at working pressure, not on port thread. In hydraulics, metering across large drops for long periods erodes the needle and seat; pressure-compensated valves confine the drop and last longer in such duty.